Skip to main content

Kinesis vs MSK (Managed Streaming for Kafka)

Overview​

Kinesis​

Amazon Kinesis is a suite of tools for collecting, processing, and analyzing real-time streaming data at scale. It includes Kinesis Data Streams, Data Firehose, Data Analytics, and Video Streams. It's fully managed by AWS and integrates seamlessly with other AWS services.

MSK (Managed Streaming for Kafka)​

Amazon Managed Streaming for Kafka (MSK) is a fully managed service that makes it easy to build and run applications that use Apache Kafka to process streaming data. MSK handles the setup, scaling, and maintenance of Kafka clusters in the cloud.

Key Differences​

  1. Core Technology:

    • Kinesis: Proprietary AWS technology designed for seamless integration with AWS ecosystem.
    • MSK: Based on open-source Apache Kafka, offering compatibility with Kafka’s ecosystem and tools.

  2. Management and Scalability:

    • Kinesis: Fully managed by AWS, with automatic scaling capabilities.
    • MSK: Also managed by AWS, but offers more control over Kafka cluster configurations.

  3. Performance:

    • Kinesis: Optimized for high throughput and real-time processing with minimal latency.
    • MSK: Focuses on high-throughput and distributed processing, potentially with slightly higher latencies.

  4. Ecosystem and Integration:

    • Kinesis: Integrates natively with AWS services like S3, Redshift, and Lambda.
    • MSK: Supports integration with Kafka-compatible tools and applications, offering a wider ecosystem outside of AWS.

  5. Use Cases:

    • Kinesis: Ideal for AWS-centric applications requiring real-time analytics, log processing, and IoT data processing.
    • MSK: Suited for applications requiring Kafka’s extensive capabilities, such as event sourcing, stream processing, and log aggregation.

  6. Pricing:

    • Kinesis: Pricing is based on the volume of data transferred and the number of shard-hours used.
    • MSK: Charged based on the number of broker-hours, storage used, and data transfer costs.

Practical Use Cases​

  • Kinesis:

    • Real-time data analytics and dashboarding in AWS environments.
    • Aggregating and processing streaming data from IoT devices.
    • Real-time log analysis and anomaly detection.

  • MSK:

    • Building scalable, high-throughput messaging systems.
    • Migrating existing Kafka-based applications to the cloud.
    • Complex event processing in distributed systems.
Building webhooks?
Svix is the enterprise ready webhooks sending service. With Svix, you can build a secure, reliable, and scalable webhook platform in minutes. Looking to send webhooks? Give it a try!

Conclusion​

Kinesis and MSK are both robust solutions for streaming data processing, each with its strengths. Kinesis is best for those deeply integrated with AWS looking for a simple, fully managed service. In contrast, MSK offers a more flexible solution for users who prefer Apache Kafka's features and its broader ecosystem. The choice depends on specific requirements, existing infrastructure, and familiarity with either AWS services or Kafka.